Exploring Unity and Diversity Across North and South India

Published 03/04/2024 in Scholar Travel Stipend
Written by Soniya Gurung | 03/04/2024

My recent week-long trip to India (Feb 12-19, 2024) provided eye-opening perspectives into the cultural unity and diversity spanning the nation. As the most populous country and seventh largest by land area, India encompasses over 1.4 billion people across a multitude of ethnicities, languages, faiths, and traditions.

This was my second trip to India, and I aimed to directly explore relationships between North and South India through visits to Goa and Bangalore. The journey connected with the core focuses of financial, physical, mental, and environmental health promulgated in the Milken Institute’s mission to tackle pressing global issues. It also aligned with the Milken Family Foundation’s commitment to education as the primary means of helping people live productive, satisfying lives within supportive communities. Gaining firsthand cultural insights heightened my understanding of India’s complex plurality as a potential asset or liability as its influence grows in the 21st century.

My trip incorporated opportunities for total cultural immersion with an Indian wedding attendance in Goa and a homestay in Bangalore. The Hindu wedding brought together families from Mumbai in North India and Hyderabad in the South. Despite regional differences, conversations with attendees emphasized pride in blending traditions through clothing, cuisine, religious rituals, music, and decor. The food reflected both Northern specialties like tandoori chicken, naan breads, rich curries and Southern dishes including dosa, idli, sambar, as well as dozens of vegetarian preparations like nutty payasam pudding (a.k.a. kheer). Though most playlists mixed popular Bollywood hits with Western pop songs, brief interludes featured classical Hindustani music from the North alongside rapid rhythmic Carnatic songs iconic to the South.

This fusion highlights India’s overall success in sustaining social cohesion amidst immense internal diversity. However, deeper discussions also revealed significant cultural stereotypes and tensions between North and South. Many Southerners characterize Northerners as culturally crass, patriarchal, and aggressive. Meanwhile, prejudices in Northern states portray Southern Indians as provincial, rigidly conservative, and overly traditional compared to India’s supposedly more “cosmopolitan” regions.

While attending elaborate wedding rituals in Goa, I gained perspective into how younger Indians increasingly accept instead of amplify such divisions. Friendships and now marriages crossing regional lines signal rising generational appreciation of cultural variety aligned with national identity. However, conversations, especially with older attendees, demonstrated lingering regional biases. The mixed reactions indicate more change must occur before regional prejudice fades completely. India’s general avoidance of major violence or separatism stemming from its internal diversity remains exceptional and important to recognize. Nonetheless, cultural divisions that breed discrimination or dysfunction may prove highly detrimental as India assumes greater prominence this century.

My Bangalore homestay provided intimate understanding of South Indian family life while revealing how local communities sustain cultural continuity. Daily routines revealed deep pride in regional customs, cuisine, faith practices, and language. Meals eaten by hand reflected the authentic way locals have consumed food for generations. My host family happily explained details around their traditions when asked but also firmly asserted ancestral ways when I ignorantly contravened norms. This demonstrated both openness and rigidness in preserving identity.

With population and economic trajectories likely making India one of the world’s preeminent powers by mid-century, social cohesion enabling that growth demands examination. Projections indicate India has surpassed China in population ahead of past predictions. Additionally, GDP growth averaging 7% over the past decade points to potential for Indian economic heft to rival China’s or America’s within coming generations. India also leads rates of improvement in human development metrics among emerging lower-middle income economies. All these factors spotlight India’s future global weight. Social stability and national unity amidst continuous regional, linguistic, class, and religious tensions shapes India’s prospects. My trip illuminated both binding and dividing forces that will determine outcomes critical for international security and development.

The relationships between diversity, development, and social welfare explored on this India trip directly connect to the Milken Institute mission of accelerating progress on global challenges encompassing financial, physical, mental, and environmental health. India currently exhibits among the world’s highest levels of income and wealth inequality. Caste hierarchies also continue generating disadvantages for minorities across health, financial, and social status realms. While India contains a burgeoning educated middle-class, class divides remain stark, often intensified through cultural differences between and within regions. As education and prosperity disseminate more widely, alleviating inequality and unifying national identity grows more feasible. But tribalism around region, language, or caste risks obstructing equitable, sustainable development even amidst robust aggregate GDP growth.

From observations in Goa and Bangalore, India clearly maintains substantial pluralism allowing for some regional variation in cultural practices, faith expression, and languages while avoiding Balkanization. This permits customization of development approaches to suit local populations. However, prejudices and privileging specific ethnicities, castes, or religions in particular areas risk balkanizing access and opportunity. The Milken Institute’s mission to blueprint evidence-based solutions for accelerating measurable progress on global challenges should thus incorporate analysis spotlighting if, when, and how variances in Indian development strategies produce inequalities undermining social cohesion and stability. Are rising regional educational and prosperity discrepancies intensifying cultural divides more than national identity? Could localized development widen wealth gaps and fuel intergroup resentment? Evaluating India’s internal dynamics around equitable growth and unity proves vital for global and regional futures.

The intense cultural immersion experiences in Goa and Bangalore also reflected core Milken Family Foundation goals around community-level education for empowering productive, fulfilling lives. Interacting with Indians from an array of backgrounds proved invaluable for comprehending complex diversity. Conversations facilitated cultural exchange vital for overcoming stereotypes and ignorance-based prejudice in Indian societies. The wedding gathering allowed younger Indians to showcase pluralism as enrichment rather than fragility for India’s global expansion. My hosts patiently explained their intricate South Indian customs, demonstrating localized pride that strengthens national identity when respectfully acknowledged. These educational interactions promoted understanding essential for countering intercultural misconceptions that divide societies.

However, India clearly remains rife with biases requiring redress through grassroots education and contact. While intergroup hostility has generally avoided violence, underlying tensions persist and likely widen amidst uneven development trajectories across regions. Educating fellow citizens about common ideals, equal dignity, shared prosperity's interdependence, and diversity’s creativity appears more constructive over forcing top-down integration seen in authoritarian states. India’s future may hinge on how humanely and effectively citizens can communicate, collaborate, and coexist with those from different backgrounds. Increasing high quality, accessible education supplemented by direct intercultural experiences thus seems critical per the Milken Family Foundation’s mission.

This India trip afforded invaluable perspective into connections binding over one billion individuals across thousands of distinct communities seeking major 21st century prominence. Interacting with North and South Indians, especially from younger generations, showed increasing national identity permeability to variety compared with rigid homogenization. However, prejudices and inequalities rooted in region, language, caste, class, ethnicity, and religion still clearly trouble full social cohesion and equitable development.

India has avoided major internal conflicts plaguing similarly diverse emerging economies. But tribal divisions may widen amidst the accelerating pace of uneven modernization transforming India. Education and intercultural awareness building can help reconciliation and pluralistic nationalism prevail over fractures. If India succeeds as a globally influential power, it can provide models for harnessing diversity as a development asset. Gaining firsthand experience with this complex country directly elucidated why research and solutions promoting internal unity align strongly with the Milken Institute and Family Foundation’s shared missions.

Decor

Wedding décor showed fusion of North and South with marigolds, coconuts, jasmines, etc. from the garlands to the entryway.